Quantcast

Home » Community »Schools » Currently Reading:

School officials: In context, ‘Trump,Trump, Trump’ chant perceived as ‘divisive’

March 1, 2017 Community, Schools 10 Comments

Editor’s Note: We are working to get more perspectives on this story. Please see more in next week’s Valley Press. If anyone would like to speak on the incident, please email jfitts@turleyct.com, I’d especially love to talk to people who attended the game. 

By John Fitts 

CANTON — Following alleged chants of “Trump, Trump, Trump” by some Canton students to an opposing team during a Tuesday evening basketball game, school officials have gone on record saying the behavior was perceived “divisive” and “disrespectful.”

The incident came during a boys game against Hartford-based Classical Magnet School when approximately 7 to 8 Canton students  yelled “Trump, Trump, Trump” while the opponents were on the free-throw line, said Superintendent Kevin  D. Case. On Thursday, Case said the tone of the chants was at issue, more than the exact words.

Two school administrators curtailed the activity at the game but Case acknowledged that some of the kids continued it after the game.

Some in the community are contending the students chose a patriotic theme for costume night and were reacting to an anti-Trump atmosphere in the schools. Others feel the chant clearly had racist overtones.

Following the incident that night, community members from both teams expressed their disappointment and the students were spoken to, Case said. Additionally, administrators met with the entire student body on Wednesday.

In a letter to parents, principal Andrew F. DiPippo said “many people perceived these comments to be divisive in the context of an athletic event.”

“While students’ right to free speech and forming educated opinions about politics and current events is a cornerstone of our education system, the exact point where political opinion converges with disrespect, discrimination, or hate speech must be separated,” he, in part, wrote. “We have a reputation as a welcoming community, and these students crossed this line with their comments and have damaged our reputation. As principal, I am disheartened that our message of community has not resonated with all students.”

Later in the letter, however, DiPippo stated he does not believe the event represents the “overall belief and values of our school community.”

“My hope in reaching out to inform families is to begin to build a broader conversation at home regarding this complex issue with your student. I was all students to feel safe and their opinions to be valued in an environment of respect. In support of this belief, please know that in school and at school events, these types of behaviors will not be allowed, and they will result in appropriate school action.”

Case said that last year the school hosted a “Truth about hate” program forum and would continue to talk about respect.

Articles on the incident have been the subject of much debate on social media, with some expressing horror at it and others saying it’s being blown out of proportion. Some have also suggested that it was done in the context of supporting Trump and a patriotic theme at the game.

Canton resident David Hudon, 1977 CHS graduate wasn’t at the game but see this not as “calling kids out for ‘unsportsmanlike conduct,” but rather one of political censorship.

“If chanting ‘miss it, miss it, miss it’ during free throws, or chanting ‘hey batter, hey batter’ at baseball games were deemed unsportsmanlike, the coach would talk to his or her players before or after the game. It would be over,” he said, reiterating a post he had made on social media. “Repeat offenders may sit out a game. That’s not what this is about. If it were, the head administrator of a school would never call all students into the auditorium to ‘discuss’ this ‘disgraceful act.’ This is about using this president’s name and that is partisan political censorship and there is absolutely no room for that in our schools

Case said that the comments did not seem to be a simple political expression, or at the very least, were not seen that way.

“The perception is that it’s divisive,” he said. “In the context of the event, it was very inappropriate.”

Case said there will be a formal apology to Classical Magnet School.

Pedro Zayas, Director of Communications and Marketing for Hartford Public Schools, said he expects further communication between Case and acting Superintendent Leslie Torres-Rodriguez.

Torres-Rodriguez was out of town but stated the following in a submitted statement, “This is an unfortunate incident that Hartford Public Schools will address urgently. We want all our students and their families to know that this is unacceptable conduct. HPS will take every step necessary to ensure that our students and families are protected from physical harm and emotional harassment. It’s sad that this would happen in an athletics setting. Schools are supposed to compete in good faith partnerships with the ultimate goal of supporting student growth. I look forward to speaking with Canton Public Schools District leadership to have a conversation on moving ahead, what we can learn, and how to prevent these kinds of situations from being repeated in the future.”

On Thursday, the Canton Board of Education also released a statement expressing disappointment in the incident, calling the behavior counter to its values.

The statement continued, The Board of Education supports the administration in its ongoing investigation of the events and has confidence it will work with the families in determining the appropriate action that should be taken. We will work with the administration to ensure that a plan is put in place to deal with all the issues highlighted by this unfortunate event, including but not limited to, diversity. As a district that accepts Open Choice students, the school administration has worked hard over the last year to create an inclusive environment through its work with the Anti-Defamation League. They and other outside organizations will be working with our school community to continue to create an inclusive environment.”

On Thursday, Case said there were police at the school following some “non-credible” threats toward Canton. Police will be at the school Friday as well, he added.

  • Ralph E Johnson

    An apology? I really dont understand. Is that any worse them MISS MISS MISS or AVON AVON AVON Just saying It is a word. Really hope that this does not get out of control.

    Hope about lets play basketball and try to stop making something out of Nothing all the time.

    How about lust playing the game and letting the kids HAVE FUN. After all I do believe that was the intent when the game was started MANY YEARS AGO.

    • Colin McEnroe

      How are young black basketball players supposed to “have fun” when white suburban kids are directing a racially intimidating chant at them?

      • cantoncompass

        approved

      • Jesse Hartman

        “Trump” is the name of the current sitting US president and not a “racially indimidating chant”. I bet those young black basketball players handled the chant better than the special-snowflake administrators did.

  • cantoncompass

    Hi folks. It’s in the banner above but based on a few emails I received, I want to remind everyone that first and last names are required for commenting. Thank you.
    John Fitts

  • Jesse Hartman

    Wow… this politically correct “safe space” nonsense has really gone too far. The name of the current sitting president, no matter how Orange he may be, is not a divisive issue, it’s simply a name. Shame on Case and the other administrators for somehow making nonsense allusions to that being “hate” speech. I expect more critical thinking in this part of the state.

  • Bill Cook

    @jessehartman:disqus and @ralphejohnson:disqus – First, I hope you’re not being serious with your arguments. Yes, “Trump” is simply a last name, but we all know exactly what was meant by it.
    When I was in high school in the 80’s, I don’t remember “Reagan!, Reagan!, Reagan!” being the chant of choice to rattle our opponents. Additionally, did these same fine young Canton citizens chant “Trump!” at the Lewis Mills team this year? Granby? Avon? You see, I actually am capable of a high level of critical thinking and I can tell you that they almost certainly didn’t.
    Donald Trump ran a campaign that gave a emboldened new voice to those that hold hate in their hearts for people that look, sound and worship differently than white America. These kids knew full well what they were doing – this was nothing more than a snarky way to chant the N word. In 2017, we should raise our kids better and punish them when they do something wrong.

    • Darrell Cookman

      Mr. Cook, I wanted to let you know that I was so impressed by your succinct take on this issue that I am printing it out to discuss with my children and students. Thank you.

  • Scott Goeben

    Does anyone know if they all shook hands after the game? It would appear that the better team won, and in more ways than the score would indicate. I’m SURE that every Canton parent that doesn’t live under a rock had a conversation with their child about what went on.
    We all love Canton, the quality of life, and especially the schools, but let’s be realistic for a minute. Go to Collinsville on any weekend, or for any big event and, regardless of what we want to believe we are not the perfect photo op for the Rainbow ColIition. Most of us warmly welcome newcomers but we still have quite a way to go.
    As for the events of the other night, if there was a blatant attempt to pull the race card and intimidate the other team then shame on all involved. If you have grown up in the Canton school system you truly know better and that’s not what you were taught.
    For the rest of us, we have been presented with an opportunity! An opportunity to have meaningful dialog with your kids about the state of the country and how to improve relationships. And as a town, we have an opportunity to prove the press wrong in their assumptions about who we are and what we believe.

    • Scott Goeben

      Zachary Goeben

VISIT OUR SPONSORS!

Turley 5

Upcoming Events

Jul
24
Mon
8:30 am Daily Mass @ St. Patrick Church
Daily Mass @ St. Patrick Church
Jul 24 @ 8:30 am
 Share this:TweetEmailPrint
1:30 pm Wii Bowling @ Canton Community Center
Wii Bowling @ Canton Community Center
Jul 24 @ 1:30 pm
Have you ever wished you could continue to bowl without putting on bowling shoes or lugging a heavy ball?  You’re in LUCK!!  Join the Canton Senior Center Wii Bowling Team, The Canton Rollers.  Show off your bowling skills or learn new ones at the Senior Center.  Mondays at 1:30pm, Wednesdays ...
Jul
25
Tue
7:30 am Canton Food Bank @ Trinity Episcopal Church
Canton Food Bank @ Trinity Episcopal Church
Jul 25 @ 7:30 am – 9:30 am
The Canton Food Bank is accepting fresh produce (as well as non-perishables of course!) every Tuesday from 7:30am-9:30am. Please keep them, and those less fortunate in our community, in mind as your backyard gardens begin to bloom and produce a bountiful harvest!  Share this:TweetEmailPrint
8:30 am Daily Mass @ St. Patrick Church
Daily Mass @ St. Patrick Church
Jul 25 @ 8:30 am
 Share this:TweetEmailPrint